Voltaire Network

Are Pakistani Generals really Mad or do they merely Feign Insanity ?

Are Pakistani Generals really Mad or do they merely Feign Insanity ?

General Musharraf thought about using the atomic bomb, when provoking the « Glaciers War », in Kargil, 1999. The release of an investigative work containing this - and other worrisome revelations – has been shaking the Indian sub-continent. But the man, who was then only occupying the position of Joint Chief of Staff, has since then seized power and is exerting it with the support of radical Islamic militants. According to General Vinod Saighal, it is urgent that the Pakistanese people overthrew an administration whose policy can bring about a regional nuclear war at any moment.

Voltaire Network | New Dehli (India)
+
JPEG - 30.7 kb
General Pervez Musharraf

"Pak Army planned ’use of N-arms’ during the Kargil War" is a sample title of the news item carried by many national dailes on October 29, 2007. The item has been excerpted from the book, Deception: Pakistan, the United States and the Global Nuclear Weapons Conspiracy by investigative journalists Adrian Levy and Catherine Scott-Clark [1]. They cite a conversation between President Bill Clinton and the Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif eight years ago when they met at Blair House in July 1999. There had been earlier instances as well where Pakistani generals came rather close to pulling the nuclear trigger according to reports that emanated from knowledgeable sources. On occasions Pakistani generals themselves have taken positions at international forums that indicated the nuclear brinkmanship on the part of the generals in power.

In the extreme volatility that obtains post-9/11 in and around Pakistan, considered by many to be the epicentre of Islamist radicalism, what should the world make of these disclosures. More importantly, what should the people of Pakistan make of the revelations that do not leave much doubt, especially based on past record, that under the sway of the military their nation is seldom far from further break up, or national suicide. For, whatever might have been the other shortcomings of the now discredited civilian prime ministers following the Zia-ul Haq era they certainly did not indulge in the type of brinkmanship that brought disaster to Pakistan on more than one occasion. Making light of the destiny of Pakistan has remained the forte of Pakistani generals.

What is more, the nuclear brinkmanship, that only Pakistani generals are capable of, could have resulted in the total destruction of Pakistan. India, committed to No-First-Use of nuclear weapons has not left Pakistani military planners in any doubt that having come under self-induced vulnerability due to N-F-U, it would have no choice but to go in for massive retaliation should Pakistan choose to exercise the nuclear option. In MAD terms it means that whereas India would suffer unimaginable horrors that, inter alia, might push India back economically by several decades, the nation of Pakistan, as presently constituted, could well disappear from the map of the world on account of its geographical size and population concentrations, especially in the Punjab. In fact, India would not even be required to target the other provinces of Pakistan, seeking deliverance from the Punjabi yoke. In as far as it concerns the radical Islamists, whose WMD targetting, by whatever means, would be directed against the West rather than India, they are fully alive to the fact that a WMD exchange with India would sizeably reduce the Muslim population of the world. In addition to the casualties within Pakistan brought on by Indian retaliatory action a few tens of million Muslims in India could also become casualties due to the Pakistani actions, i.e., the Muslim ummat gets hit both ways through no fault of theirs, merely because Pakistan remains a state run by the military-jehadi combine, whatever the innocent disclaimers from time to time at the apex of the Pakistan military hierarchy.

China, the all-weather friend of Pakistan, is no friend of the ordinary people of Pakistan, if looked at objectively. The atheist communist dispensation that runs China is more comfortable with the non-democratic military dispensation in Pakistan. Casualties numbering in the millions have never disturbed the sleep of autocratic regimes anywhere in the world. The Chinese have nearly settled their problems in the outlying western provinces occupied by them after the Maoist take-over through genocide in Xiniang and Tibet. They have assisted Pakistan to become a nuclear power not out of deep friendship for the Muslims of that country. Pakistan has been set up as a formidable adversary against India to serve China’s geostrategic interests in the subcontinent and the adjoining regions. The latter would not be overly upset by a full-scale exchange between Pakistan and India so that India is reduced to a third-rate economic power rather than a future competitor to China’s economic might. That is why they have helped Pakistan with missile technologies that augment the range to target Bangalore and the Indian IT hubs. In the bargain, should Pakistan simply go under, just too bad.

In the light of the above the people of Pakistan have to wake up from their military-induced somnolence to retrieve the destiny of their country - and their place in the sun - from the military and the mullahs before it becomes too late. The question of another war between the nations of the subcontinent should simply not arise.

[1] Deception: Pakistan, the United States and the Global Nuclear Weapons Consipracy, by Adrian Levy and Catherine Scott-Clark, Atlantic Books, September 2007.

General Vinod Saighal

Major-General Vinod Saighal is a former general director of the Indian army’s military training. He was an embassy military attaché in France and Benelux, and commander-in-chief of the peacekeeping forces in the Near East. Today he is the founder of the Movement for Restoration of Good Government (MRGG) and head of Eco Monitors Society (EMS). He is the author of numerous works on strategy and political analysis, and has recently published Dealing with Global Terrorism: The Way Forward. He is member of the anti-imperialist conference Axis for Peace.

 
Why is the situation in Pakistan irremediable?
Why is the situation in Pakistan irremediable?
The Assassination of Benazir Bhutto, according to an Indian General
 
Nuclear Issues
Since President Truman’s decision to detonate two atomic bombs over Japan in a show of U.S. military strength vis-à-vis the Soviets to deter them from retaliating against the Anglo-Saxons at the end of World War 2, numerous initiatives have been undertaken to dissuade Washington from replicating similar crimes. Whereas the USSR acquired its own bomb opening the door to proliferation, neutral States advocated in favour of a nuclear-free world. The international treaties in force consecrate the strategic edge gained by the big powers while depriving the smaller ones of nuclear weapons. These are exploited politically to condemn - rightly or wrongly - insubordinate States (Iran, North Korea) and to protect friendly nations (Israel, India-Pakistan). In the context of the U.S. economic crisis, Obama attempted to reopen denuclearization negotiations. However, vast regions of the planet have already been contaminated, either for having served as nuclear testing grounds or as a combat theater where depleted uranium was used.
+

Article licensed under Creative Commons

The articles on Voltaire Network may be freely reproduced provided the source is cited, their integrity is respected and they are not used for commercial purposes (license CC BY-NC-ND).

Support Voltaire Network

You visit this website to seek quality analysis that enables you to forge your own understanding of today’s world. In order to continue our work, we need you to support our efforts.
Help us by making a contribution.

How to participate in Voltaire Network?

The members of our team are all volunteers.
- Authors : diplomats, economists, geographers, historians, journalists, military servicemen, philosophers, sociologists. You can send us your article proposals.
- Professional-level mother-tongue translators: you can help us by translating our articles.

International edition
français
English
Español
italiano
عربي
Deutsch
 
96 <span lang='fr'>articles cette semaine dans toutes les langues</span>
Al-Qaida frappe à Alep
« Presseschau Syrien » #50
Al-Qaida frappe à Alep
Partenaires, 13 février 2012
 
Páginas Libres
¿Magia o mano negra en Movistar?
por Guillermo Olivera Díaz, Socios, 13 de febrero de 2012
 
Le Qatar achète la démission du général al-Dabi Le Qatar achète la démission du général al-Dabi
Réseau Voltaire, 13 février 2012
 
2012, année de tous les périls ? 2012, année de tous les périls ?
par Joseph Stiglitz, Réseau Voltaire, 13 février 2012
 
Jeux de guerre états-uniens dans le sud-est asiatique Jeux de guerre états-uniens dans le sud-est asiatique
Réseau Voltaire, 13 février 2012
 
مجلس التعاون الخليجي والناتو يفقدان زمام القيادة
الفيتو المزدوج لمنع حرب الإمبراطوريات على سوريا
مجلس التعاون الخليجي والناتو يفقدان زمام القيادة
بقلم ثييري ميسان, Shabakat Voltaire, 13 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
الصين تصبح الشريك التجاري الأول لألمانيا الصين تصبح الشريك التجاري الأول لألمانيا
Shabakat Voltaire, 13 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
Iran's Historic Anniversary Iran’s Historic Anniversary
by Stephen Lendman, Voltaire Network, 13 February 2012
 
Páginas Libres
Mafia de complicidad y reacción en el Apra
Socios, 12 de febrero de 2012
 
Syria 2011-2012, a rematch of Israel's 2006 war on Lebanon Syria 2011-2012, a rematch of Israel’s 2006 war on Lebanon
by Mahdi Darius Nazemroaya, Voltaire Network, 12 February 2012
 
Páginas Libres
¿Se incrementa riesgo personal con este gobierno?
por Guillermo Olivera Díaz, Socios, 12 de febrero de 2012
 
Ante la competencia de la OCS, ¿escogerá la OTAN la diplomacia o las armas?
« Revista de prensa sobre Siria » #49
Ante la competencia de la OCS, ¿escogerá la OTAN la diplomacia o las armas?
Socios, 12 de febrero de 2012
 
Wladimir Putin tritt als Beschützer der Orient-Christen auf Wladimir Putin tritt als Beschützer der Orient-Christen auf
Voltaire Netzwerk, 12. Februar 2012
 
Großbritannien „verpackt“ die Al-Qaida neu Großbritannien „verpackt“ die Al-Qaida neu
Voltaire Netzwerk, 12. Februar 2012
 
Moscow and the formation of The New World System Moscow and the formation of The New World System
by Imad Fawzi Shueibi, Voltaire Network, 11 February 2012
 
Assassinats anonymes
« L’art de la guerre »
Assassinats anonymes
par Manlio Dinucci , Réseau Voltaire, 11 février 2012
 
Sergei Lavrov von Damaskus als Held empfangen Sergei Lavrov von Damaskus als Held empfangen
Voltaire Netzwerk, 11. Februar 2012
 
Al-Qaeda refashioned by the UK Al-Qaeda refashioned by the UK
Voltaire Network, 11 February 2012
 
الإرهاب في سورية
إغلاق السفارات والارهاب في حلب
بقلم مازن بلال, Partners, 11 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
حلب تستفيق على الإرهاب...
وتصعيد دبلوماسي إعلامي وإرهابي
بقلم سورية الغد, Partners, 11 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
الإرهاب في سورية
أغفو في وطني
بقلم نضال الخضري, Partners, 11 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
الإرهاب في سورية
التحرك الخليجي إلى أين...
بقلم مازن بلال, Partners, 11 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
Páginas Libres
¿Sófero retroceso post marcha por el agua?
por Guillermo Olivera Díaz, Socios, 11 de febrero de 2012
 
Face à la concurrence de l'OCS, l'OTAN choisira t-elle la diplomatie ou les armes ?
« Revue de presse Syrie » #49
Face à la concurrence de l’OCS, l’OTAN choisira t-elle la diplomatie ou les armes ?
Partenaires, 10 février 2012
 
 Im Wettstreit mit der SCO, wird die NATO Diplomatie oder Waffen wählen?
« Presseschau Syrien » #49
Im Wettstreit mit der SCO, wird die NATO Diplomatie oder Waffen wählen?
Partner, 10. Februar 2012
 
U.S. Prepares Georgia for New Wars in Caucasus and Iran
"NATO’s favorite despot"
U.S. Prepares Georgia for New Wars in Caucasus and Iran
by Rick Rozoff, Voltaire Network, 10 February 2012
 
La Grande-Bretagne « reconditionne » Al-Qaïda La Grande-Bretagne « reconditionne » Al-Qaïda
Réseau Voltaire, 10 février 2012
 
Faced with competition from the SCO, will NATO choose diplomacy or arms?
« SYRIA PRESS REVIEW » #49
Faced with competition from the SCO, will NATO choose diplomacy or arms?
Partners, 10 February 2012
 
Señal de Alerta
Risas inexplicables en la radio
por Herbert Mujica Rojas, Socios, 10 de febrero de 2012
 
Vladimir Putin emerges as protector of Eastern Christians Vladimir Putin emerges as protector of Eastern Christians
Voltaire Network, 9 February 2012
 
Censura británica: cómo seguir viendo Press TV Censura británica: cómo seguir viendo Press TV
Red Voltaire, 9 de febrero de 2012
 
El CCG y la OTAN pierden su liderazgo
El doble veto prohíbe la guerra imperial contra Siria
El CCG y la OTAN pierden su liderazgo
por Thierry Meyssan, Red Voltaire, 9 de febrero de 2012
 
Westerners looking for a "Plan B"
« SYRIA PRESS REVIEW » #48
Westerners looking for a "Plan B"
Partners, 9 February 2012
 
 Der Westen sucht den « B » Plan
« Presseschau Syrien » #48
Der Westen sucht den « B » Plan
Partner, 9. Februar 2012
 
Páginas Libres
¡Yo voto por el agua, el oro ni me va ni me viene!
por Guillermo Olivera Díaz, Socios, 9 de febrero de 2012
 
Les Occidentaux à la recherche d'un “Plan B”
« Revue de presse Syrie » #48
Les Occidentaux à la recherche d’un “Plan B”
Partenaires, 9 février 2012
 
Los occidentales buscan un “Plan B”
« Revista de prensa sobre Siria » #48
Los occidentales buscan un “Plan B”
Socios, 9 de febrero de 2012
 
Sergey Lavrov accueilli en héros à Damas Sergey Lavrov accueilli en héros à Damas
Réseau Voltaire, 8 février 2012
 
Russia's popularity in Syria confounds the West
« SYRIA PRESS REVIEW » #47
Russia’s popularity in Syria confounds the West
Partners, 8 February 2012
 
255. Il faut à nouveau faire jouer l'« orchestre européen »
« Horizons et débats », 12e année, n° 5, 6 février 2012
Il faut à nouveau faire jouer l’« orchestre européen »
Partenaires, 8 février 2012
 
China becomes German's first trading partner China becomes German’s first trading partner
Voltaire Network, 8 February 2012
 
Syrie : Le double véto russo-chinois inaugure un nouvel ordre mondial Syrie : Le double véto russo-chinois inaugure un nouvel ordre mondial
par Pierre Khalaf, Partenaires, 8 février 2012
 
China wird erster Wirtschaftspartner von Deutschland China wird erster Wirtschaftspartner von Deutschland
Voltaire Netzwerk, 8. Februar 2012
 
Señal de Alerta
Etica bananera
por Herbert Mujica Rojas, Socios, 8 de febrero de 2012
 
Un avion cargo suspect saisi par la sécurité libanaise Un avion cargo suspect saisi par la sécurité libanaise
Réseau Voltaire, 8 février 2012
 
فرنسوا هولند يفاوض أمير قطر فرنسوا هولند يفاوض أمير قطر
Shabakat Voltaire, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
 الدبلوماسيات الغاضبة وسيناريوهات الحلول الدبلوماسيات الغاضبة وسيناريوهات الحلول
بقلم عيسى الأيوبي, Shabakat Voltaire, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
أبعد من انتصار نيويورك..اللعبة انتهت أبعد من انتصار نيويورك..اللعبة انتهت
بقلم عيسى الأيوبي, Shabakat Voltaire, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
جلسة الكذب المفتوح جلسة الكذب المفتوح
بقلم عيسى الأيوبي, Shabakat Voltaire, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
Egypt and Syria
Orient Tendencies
Egypt and Syria
by Wassim Raad, Partners, 8 February 2012
 
Les Occidentaux choqués par la popularité russe en Syrie
« Revue de presse Syrie » #47
Les Occidentaux choqués par la popularité russe en Syrie
Partenaires, 8 février 2012
 
كسر إرادات
عروبة ((الشاطئ)) الآخر
بقلم نضال الخضري, Partners, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
كسر إرادات
زيارة لافروف ... ودول الخليج تضغط
بقلم سورية الغد, Partners, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
كسر إرادات
مواقف في لحظات الترقب
بقلم سورية الغد, Partners, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
كسر إرادات
التكتيك الخليجي
بقلم مازن بلال, Partners, 8 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
 Der Westen über die russische Beliebtheit in Syrien schockiert
« Presseschau Syrien » #47
Der Westen über die russische Beliebtheit in Syrien schockiert
Partner, 8. Februar 2012
 
Disgusto de los occidentales ante la popularidad rusa en Siria
« Revista de prensa sobre Siria » #47
Disgusto de los occidentales ante la popularidad rusa en Siria
Socios, 8 de febrero de 2012
 
Moscou et Pékin ont surtout voulu protéger Téhéran
« Revue de presse Syrie » #46
Moscou et Pékin ont surtout voulu protéger Téhéran
Partenaires, 7 février 2012
 
Páginas Libres
MOVADEF y SL: reflexiones estudiantiles
Socios, 7 de febrero de 2012
 
Páginas Libres
Gran Marcha por el Agua: viernes 10, 2 pm
por Guillermo Olivera Díaz, Socios, 7 de febrero de 2012
 
Moscow and Beijing acted primarily to shield Tehran
« SYRIA PRESS REVIEW » #46
Moscow and Beijing acted primarily to shield Tehran
Partners, 7 February 2012
 
 Der GCC und die NATO verlieren ihre Vorherrschaft
Doppeltes Veto um den imperialen Krieg gegen Syrien zu verbieten
Der GCC und die NATO verlieren ihre Vorherrschaft
von Thierry Meyssan, Voltaire Netzwerk, 7. Februar 2012
 
Páginas Libres
¡Luz roja al solmáforo!
Socios, 7 de febrero de 2012
 
Más que todo, Moscú y Pekín quisieron proteger a Teherán
« Revista de prensa sobre Siria » #46
Más que todo, Moscú y Pekín quisieron proteger a Teherán
Socios, 7 de febrero de 2012
 
 Moskau und Beijing wollten hauptsächlich Teheran schützen
« Presseschau Syrien » #46
Moskau und Beijing wollten hauptsächlich Teheran schützen
Partner, 7. Februar 2012
 
Páginas Libres
Alan y Ollanta ocultaron tratos de indulto ilícito a Fujimori
por Guillermo Olivera Díaz, Socios, 6 de febrero de 2012
 
روسيا وتشكيل المنظومة الدولية
الثابت والمتغير في المواقف
روسيا وتشكيل المنظومة الدولية
بقلم Imad Fawzi Shueibi, Shabakat Voltaire, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
رسالة أوباما إلى طهران، الحرب على إيران على نارٍ هادئة... في الوقت الحالي؟ رسالة أوباما إلى طهران، الحرب على إيران على نارٍ هادئة... في الوقت الحالي؟
بقلم Mahdi Darius Nazemroaya, Shabakat Voltaire, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
Páginas Libres
Iglesia católica en conflicto peruano-chileno
Socios, 6 de febrero de 2012
 
 Il GCC e la NATO stanno perdendo la loro leadership
Il doppio veto che impedisce la guerra imperiale contro la Siria
Il GCC e la NATO stanno perdendo la loro leadership
di Thierry Meyssan, Rete Voltaire, 6 febbraio 2012
 
الأوروبيون... أول ضحايا العقوبات على إيران الأوروبيون... أول ضحايا العقوبات على إيران
Shabakat Voltaire, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
ثرثرة
لـ((أغلبية صامتة))!!
بقلم نضال الخضري, Partners, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
سورية
الحدث من حمص
بقلم سورية الغد, Partners, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
التحرك الروسي
وذروة الأزمة
بقلم مازن بلال, Partners, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
قبل وصول لافروف...
ما الذي ستحمله موسكو؟!
بقلم سورية الغد, Partners, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
على أوباما خيارات صعبة في وقت حرج
التقرير الأسبوعي لمراكز الأبحاث الأميركية
على أوباما خيارات صعبة في وقت حرج
Shabakat Voltaire, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012
 
التهديد باغلاق المضيق و تداعياته
التقرير الأسبوعي لمراكز الدراسات الأميركية
التهديد باغلاق المضيق و تداعياته
Shabakat Voltaire, 6 شباط (فبراير) 2012