Voltaire Network

“Democracy in a cartoon”

+

The Danish caricatures bring the most important problem of our times up: the freedom of expression. Are we Westerners going to give in to the pressures of a medieval society or are we going to defend our most valuable worth: freedom, the freedom of expression, an achievement for which millions of people have died for?
There’s no democracy without freedom: freedom of debate, of disagreement or insulting and offending, even. This is a freedom the Islamic world does not have and without it, the Islam will always be dogmatic, fanatic and medieval. Without this fundamental freedom, the Islam will keep suppressing thoughts, human rights, individual rights, originality and truth. If we don’t show our solidarity with the Danish caricaturists in an open and public way, unashamed, then the forces that try to impose a totalitarian ideology in the free West today will succeed: the Islamization of Europe would begin. First of all, we should not apologize.
This brings a more general problem up: the inability of the West to defend itself in cultural and intellectual terms. Be proud of not apologizing. Should we keep apologizing for the sins of our fathers? Should we apologize, for instance, for what the British Empire did when what it actually brought about was the rebirth of India, the fight against hunger, the construction of the railroad, roads, irrigation systems, the elimination of cholera, the creation of the public service, the implementation of an educational system where none of these existed? And, above all, the solid implementation of a parliamentarian society to face the kinglets and the force of law to face the royal arbitrariness. The English even allowed the Indians to rediscover their past: thanks to the scholarships, archaeology, and the European studies the old Indian greatness was known; it was the British Empire the one who worked to save and preserve the monuments that witnessed this glory. The British imperialism did care about preservation where the former Islamic imperialism destroyed thousands of Indian temples.
At the world level, should we apologize for the birth of Dante, Shakespeare and Goethe? Mozart, Beethoven and Bach? Rembrandt, Vermeer, Van Gogh, Breughel, Ter Borch? Galileo, Huygens, Copernicus, Newton and Darwin? For having invented penicillin and computers? For the Olympic games and football? For human rights and parliamentarian democracy? It was in the West where the ideas of individual freedom, political democracy, law, Human Rights and cultural freedom were born. The West has imposed the status of women, and has fought against slavery, has defended the freedom of research, expression and beliefs. The West does not need the lessons of virtue of the societies that keep women submitted, where their clitorises are severed and where they are stoned to death if suspected of adultery, where acid is thrown to the faces of or where Human Rights are denied to those who are considered lower classes.
How can we ask immigrants to integrate into the Western society when at the same time they are taught that the West is decadent, corrupted, the source of all wrongs, racist, imperialist and despicable? Why, according to the words of Afro-American writer James Baldwin, would they board a sinking ship? Why do all these people try to emigrate to our countries and not to Saudi Arabia? We’d do better if we teach them the history of the centuries of struggle that brought about the freedoms they enjoy today; the history of the individuals and groups that fought for those freedoms and who are nowadays disregarded, degraded and forgotten. We’d do good if we make emphasis on the freedoms that a great part of the world envies, admires and tries to emulate with. When the Chinese students died for democracy at the Tiananmen Square in 1989, they were not carrying the images of Confucius or Buddha, but a copy of the Statue of Liberty.
The freedom of expression is our Western heritage and we must defend it or it will succumb to totalitarian attacks. This freedom is also essential for the Islamic world. By defending our values we give an important lesson to the Islamic world, we allow them to compare their old and sacred traditions with our values.

Source
Der Spiegel (Germany)
Circulation: 1 100 000 copies. An important investigation magazine issued for the first time in 1947, and source of multiple political scandals. It is known for its own journalistic slang and also issues four special editions yearly. The website of the Spiegel is the most successful online magazine in Germany.

Democracy in a cartoon”, by Ibn Warraq, Der Spiegel, February 5, 2006. Text adapted from an interview.

Ibn Warraq

Ibn Warraq est le nom de plume d’un pamphlétaire anonyme, se prétendant d’origine pakistanaise et vivant aux États-Unis. Affirmant avoir étudié dans une école coranique, il a rompu avec la religion et décrit son expérience dans un ouvrage best-seller Why I am Not a Muslim. Certains théologiens islamiques qui partagent ses critiques vis à vis de l’islam ont néanmoins mis en doute l’authenticité de sa biographie, notant dans ses ouvrages des erreurs grossières concernant l’islam. Ibn Warraq est le cofondateur de l’Institute for the Secularisation of Islamic Society (ISIS), un mouvement politique athée et laïc, financé par les États-Unis. Il est le chouchou des intellectuels néo-conservateurs et libéraux voyant en lui un « Voltaire de l’islam » qui pourra « mener les musulmans aux Lumières ».

 
Voltaire Network

Voltaire, international edition

Article licensed under Creative Commons

The articles on Voltaire Network may be freely reproduced provided the source is cited, their integrity is respected and they are not used for commercial purposes (license CC BY-NC-ND).

Support Voltaire Network

You visit this website to seek quality analysis that enables you to forge your own understanding of today’s world. In order to continue our work, we need you to support our efforts.
Help us by making a contribution.

How to participate in Voltaire Network?

The members of our team are all volunteers.
- Authors : diplomats, economists, geographers, historians, journalists, military servicemen, philosophers, sociologists. You can send us your article proposals.
- Professional-level mother-tongue translators: you can help us by translating our articles.

210. The Swiss Gold Reserves
«Current Concerns», n° 27, 11 November 2014
The Swiss Gold Reserves
Partners
 
209. Popular initiative “Save our Swiss Gold”
«Current Concerns», n° 26, 28 October 2014
Popular initiative “Save our Swiss Gold”
Partners
 
208. Washington wants to change the regime in Russia
«Current Concerns», n° 25, 12 October 2014
Washington wants to change the regime in Russia
Partners
 
207. The long Swiss humanitarian tradition
«Current Concerns», n° 23/24, 5 October 2014
The long Swiss humanitarian tradition
Partners
 
Asian Games: Putin 2 - Obama 0
"The art of war"
Asian Games: Putin 2 - Obama 0
by Manlio Dinucci, Voltaire Network