Voltaire Network

France’s AFP News Agency Manipulated Statements by Swiss Foreign Minister Calmy-Rey and Accused her of Trying to Negotiate with Bin Laden

| Geneva (Switzerland)
+

A deplorable action. AFP News Agency (Agence France Presse), one of major world information entities and whose bulletins serve of «raw material» to thousands of daily newspapers around the world, has used honest, sincere and intelligent statements by the head of Helvetic Diplomacy, Micheline Calmy-Rey, who gave a political speech betting on dialog among nations as a means to solve world conflicts, and to avoid wars among the countries and other calamities.

AFP has outrageously distorted Calmy-Rey´s statements and misinformed the public.

The AFP article reads like this:

«Switzerland’s foreign minister raised the possibility of direct talks with Osama Bin Laden and with Al Qaida.»

The misinformation was mirrored and amplified by the Atlantist Parisian daily Le Monde, which used the following headline for its article:

«Swiss Foreign Minister is ready to sit at the bargaining table with Bin Laden»[1]

Micheline Calmy-Rey made her statement last August 25 in Berne, the country’s federal city capital, in the context of the inauguration of the conference of [Swiss] ambassadors. Her speech was titled «Switzerland’s Foreign Policy: Between Dialog and Exclusion.»

Calmy-Rey’s speech was an effort to warn on the large number of conflicts underway in the world and to recall that dialog is an efficient way to deactivate such conflicts; a dialog that can be achieved with interlocutors that are not or do not constitute a state. Micheline Calmy-Rey took the occasion to criticize a species of pseudo-moralistic or pseudo-thinking people who oppose all kinds of dialog with anti-establishment groups [either national or foreign, rebel or guerrilla, secessionist or separatist, etc]. Those pseudo-thinkers or pseudo-moralists see violence or repression as the only ways to solve disputes.

Calmy-Rey also points out that «some become indignant when they find in this realistic practice a way to favor [or support] some kind of proto-terrorism. Do not let us be misguided: dialog does not inexorably leads to accepting what is unacceptable; understanding does not translate into admitting and it does not mean complicity [either]. Dialog is undoubtedly based on commitment; though finding commitment in no way stands for compromising the values we deeply believe in.

Then, do we have to listen to those pseudo-thinkers? Or look for dialog without discrimination-[and she ironically adds] facing the danger of finding ourselves sitting at the [bargaining] table with Osama Bin Laden? [2]

The Swill governemnt spokes person has protested and denounce the bad faith of the AFP reporter [see official protest in English and in French].

The Swiss foreign minister has large experience in conflict mediation; she supports and promotes dialog channels in several parts of the world, for instance between Palestinians and Israelis, between the Colombian government and the FARC guerrillas.

See attachment: the interesting and full speech by the Swiss foreign minister in French.

Attached documents

 
Sandro Cruz

Sandro Cruz Journalist. Vice-Chairman of Voltaire Network ; president of IPI news agency and Timéli Publications Inc.

 
2008 Presidential Campaign USA: An Anti-Democratic Show
2008 Presidential Campaign USA: An Anti-Democratic Show
Interview with Thierry Meyssan about the Electoral Process in the United States
 
Voltaire Network

Voltaire, international edition

325. Can democracy be reduced to computers?
Can democracy be reduced to computers?
«Current Concerns», n°8, April 2, 2019
 
322. The project of a Swiss-EU agreement
The project of a Swiss-EU agreement
«Current Concerns», n°4, February 21, 2019
 
312. Switzerland, a humanitarian spirit
Switzerland, a humanitarian spirit
«Current Concerns», n°22, October 9, 2018
 

Article licensed under Creative Commons

The articles on Voltaire Network may be freely reproduced provided the source is cited, their integrity is respected and they are not used for commercial purposes (license CC BY-NC-ND).

Support Voltaire Network

You visit this website to seek quality analysis that enables you to forge your own understanding of today’s world. In order to continue our work, we need you to support our efforts.
Help us by making a contribution.

How to participate in Voltaire Network?

The members of our team are all volunteers.
- Professional-level mother-tongue translators: you can help us by translating our articles.